Holiday baking and food sensitivities in Canada: butter tarts, tourtière, Nanaimo bars and eggnog

| Written by: Test My Food Sensitivity Team | 21 min read
Tray of small golden baked tarts in a bakery

Ask a room of Canadians whether a butter tart should have raisins and you'll start an argument. The butter tart is one of the country's best-loved sweets: a small pastry shell filled with butter, brown sugar, syrup and egg, baked until the top crackles and the middle stays runny. At Christmas it sits on the dessert tray beside Nanaimo bars, with tourtière for dinner and a glass of eggnog nearby.

This guide is built around that one butter tart, because it holds several of the foods people most often ask about in one bite. It covers what is in it, how to read a Canadian label, how to plan a holiday baking season, and where an at-home sensitivity test can fit.

Tray of small golden baked tarts in a bakery

What is in a butter tart

The classic butter tart filling is butter, brown sugar, maple or corn syrup and egg, baked in a pastry shell. The earliest published recipe comes from Barrie, Ontario, in 1900, and Midland, Ontario, now holds one of the biggest butter tart festivals in the country. Families argue about raisins, walnuts and pecans.

That gives you a short list of ingredients to think about:

  • Wheat, in the pastry.
  • Milk, in the butter, and often in the pastry too.
  • Egg, in the filling.
  • Tree nuts, if walnuts or pecans go in.

The rest of the holiday tray is similar. Nanaimo bars, from Nanaimo in British Columbia, layer a crumb base with a custard-flavoured filling and chocolate. Tourtière is a spiced meat pie with a wheat crust. Eggnog is milk, cream and egg.

Reading a Canadian label

Health Canada lists the priority food allergens: eggs, milk, mustard, peanuts, crustaceans and molluscs, fish, sesame seeds, soy, sulphites, tree nuts, and wheat and triticale. Canadian rules require these, along with gluten sources and added sulphites, to be clearly identified by their common names on pre-packaged foods. If you buy butter tarts from a supermarket or bakery chain, the label should show wheat, milk, egg and any nuts. A tart from a church sale or a neighbour's kitchen won't have a label, so ask.

A baking-season plan

Holiday baking stretches over weeks, with a cookie exchange here, an office tray there, and a lot of small tastes. That makes it hard to say what sat badly. A simple plan helps:

  • Bake your own batch and change one ingredient at a time. For example, make one batch with butter and one with a dairy-free spread, and note which you feel better after.
  • Keep nuts separate. Bake a plain batch and a nut batch so you can compare.
  • Pace the tray. Two tarts with a coffee is a different test from six across an evening.

Our free food and symptom diary template has room for snacks as well as meals.

Allergy or sensitivity?

An allergy is a fast immune reaction that can be serious. A sensitivity or intolerance usually brings slower, uncomfortable symptoms such as bloating, headaches or tiredness. Every food on the butter tart list appears in Health Canada's priority allergens, so if anyone has had swelling or breathing trouble after eating, that is a matter for a doctor first.

Almost 11% of adults have a true food allergy, yet 19% believe they do. Many are actually dealing with a food intolerance or sensitivity (JAMA Network Open, 2019).

Where an at-home sensitivity test fits

A season of baking can leave you with more questions than answers. When the diary keeps flagging two or three ingredients at once, our Optimum Sensitivity Test offers a wider look. Mail in a little hair and we compare it against 1,600 food and non-food items, including wheat, dairy, egg and nuts. It is designed for wellness, not medicine. Instructions come digitally, and results are emailed 5 to 7 working days after your sample lands with us.

Baking for a household? There's an Optimum 2-pack and an Optimum 4-pack, with current prices on the product page. For Canadian options side by side, see how to get a food sensitivity test in Canada.

A note on your doctor

Bring your notes to your family doctor before cutting anything out long term. Most provinces offer a nurse line on 811. Our test is not an allergy test and won't replace medical advice. Dial 911 if anyone's face or throat swells, or they struggle to breathe, after eating.

You might be interested in

View all